Blog Home
Blog Archives
LittleGhost Home
Blog Archives
LittleGhost Home
E-mail: geistlinger AT gmail.com
Loading
Pic 'O the Day
Top 10 Lists
Everyone loves lists
Reviews
Books, Movies and so on
Blogroll
Dave Winer
Kottke
Groklaw (PJ)
Whiskey Bar (billmon)
Kevin Drum
Josh Marshall
War and Piece
Kasia - Unix-Girl
Jeremy Zawodny
Dooce.com (Heather A.)
Tim Bray
Robert Scoble
Scott Rosenberg
Kottke
Groklaw (PJ)
Whiskey Bar (billmon)
Kevin Drum
Josh Marshall
War and Piece
Kasia - Unix-Girl
Jeremy Zawodny
Dooce.com (Heather A.)
Tim Bray
Robert Scoble
Scott Rosenberg
Feed Me!
Feeds I Read
Theme
Listening To...
Evidence of Efforts
![[Valid RSS]](/images/valid-rss.png "Validate my RSS feed"){kind=small}
Recent Posts
• Standards - But for Content
A short note about ho...
• Monkey Pox While there is not yet any definitive ...
• What the Internet Is/Isn't An old article got an ...
• The Clubies This is my own award program, designe...
• The HTTP Dance As I've noted in previous entries,...
• Why the Grammys Don't Matter I've been saying for...
• Data Diving Continued - mySQL Issues Another tren...
• Data Diving Coming from a background that include...
• The Shortest and Longest Month of the Year Februa...
• Linux Faithful Still Getting It Wrong As the cont...
• Monkey Pox While there is not yet any definitive ...
• What the Internet Is/Isn't An old article got an ...
• The Clubies This is my own award program, designe...
• The HTTP Dance As I've noted in previous entries,...
• Why the Grammys Don't Matter I've been saying for...
• Data Diving Continued - mySQL Issues Another tren...
• Data Diving Coming from a background that include...
• The Shortest and Longest Month of the Year Februa...
• Linux Faithful Still Getting It Wrong As the cont...
Sunday, February 15, 2004
Leaked Windows Code
This is not fresh news (can't really say new news...), but here are my thoughts on the subject:
- *yawn*
- There will continue to be much speculation about the ramifications of this leak (real? by Linux fans? publicity stunt? Will someone release a new OS based on this code??). However, the speculations will rapidly die out, as already evidenced by the drop-off of interest in this subject, less than a week after the release of a small portion of Win2000/WinNT code.
- *yawn*
In other words, a lot of sound and fury, signifying nothing, really.
However, I did read one remarkably clueless comment on the matter that's worth repeating - from Dave Winer, who should know better:
Everyone's so worried about the Microsoft source leak. "It could open new security holes!" they say. But check this out, the source for Linux, a popular Microsoft competitor, has always been available, and this is promoted by its advocates saying it makes Linux more secure, not less. More programmer eyeballs looking for bugs. Maybe some white-hat types will try to check in some fixes for Windows 2000? Stranger things have happened.
- Dave Winer
- Dave Winer
Yes, stranger things have happened, but consider the following:
- Linux code is spozed to be out in the open; Windoze code is not
- Linux code has a process for anyone to submit bugs; Windoze does not (in the traditional, OS build sense). Exactly where will these White Hats check in their code?
- Submit a Windoze bug fix? Go to court - you've just admitted to working with trade secrets/copyrighted code or what have you
While I understand what Winer was trying to say, it really didn't make a whole lot of sense. To me.