Blog This!   Lee Geistlinger's Web Log

Blog Home
Blog Archives
LittleGhost Home

E-mail: geistlinger AT gmail.com

Everyone loves lists Books, Movies and so on

My Online Aggregator

Why SVG is Doomed

I write this more as a prognostication/plea than as a fact.

I hope SVG is not doomed.

But I think it is. (Here's a nice historical overview of SVG [note: PDF] ).

Here's why:

• SVG has been around since 1998 as a working draft (to get around the limitations of PostScript for Web use). That's over five years. Half the Web's life.


• 99% of average users - including I would guess ~75+% of Web developers/designers - have never heard of SVG (ouch!)


• 75+% of average users - including I would guess ~99% of Web developers/designers - have heard of Flash (another vector-graphic tool)


• Flash comes with most browsers; installation for those without is straightforward


• Few users - a statistically insignificant percentage - have the SVG plug-in


• You can buy (Macromedia) Flash-building tools. Robust, well-accepted and integrated tools


• SVG requires hand-coding in many cases; few programs output native SVG code (With the sole exception of Adobe Illustrator, no major programs)


• SVG's acceptance and market penetration is following the same trajectory as VRML - yes, the forgotten VRML...


• MS's Longhorn (as currently planned) is going to come with its own proprietary vector-graphic tools. Why invest in making/building tools/app for SVG when MS is poised to crush them/it?

Hey, I'm not happy about this, but let's be real about it. It does not look good.